Tampa Bay Newspapers
9911 Seminole Blvd.,
Seminole, FL 33772
Phone: (727) 397-5563
Fax: (727) 397-5900
Submit News
  
 Search
  9911 Seminole Blvd. Seminole, FL 33772       Ph. 727-397-5563   View TBN's FREE e-Edition today!  
Click here to learn more
Clearwater Beacon
Home lawsuit gets pricey for the city
Defining meaning of term is $200,000 and counting
Article published on Thursday, Dec. 12, 2013
  Print E-Mail
 
CLEARWATER – Normally, determining the meaning of a two-word phrase is as simple as looking it up in a dictionary or on the Internet. But when lawyers are involved, things aren’t that easy.

The taxpayers of Clearwater have already spent $40,000 trying to nail down the definition of the term “substantial improvement.” And at the Dec. 5 meeting, the Clearwater City Council gave City Attorney Pam Akin the go-ahead to spend $160,000 more.

The dispute has been dragging on since April 2001, when David and Aileen Bair decided to remodel their Island Estates home and they filed a request for the required permit with the city’s Planning and Development Department.

“Because the property is below the 100-year flood elevation and is located in a ‘V’ flood zone, the Community Development Code requires any ‘substantial improvements’ to existing structures to comply with the flood drainage-resistance provisions, including that the structure is elevated,” a memo from the city’s legal department to the city council explained. “‘Substantial improvement’ is defined as the ‘reconstruction, rehabilitation, addition or other improvement of a structure during a one-year period, the cost of which exceeds 50 percent of the market value of the structure before the construction of the improvement.”’

A building official from the city required the Bairs to submit a “non-substantial improvement application” and backup material to prove that the work was not a “substantial improvement.” A building permit was issued in July 2011, although the legal department memo does not explain the reason for the decade-long delay between the filing of the application and the issuance of the permit.

Work began in August 2011 but was halted when a city inspector determined that the changes were a “substantial improvement” of the property and issued a Stop Work Order. The Bairs then appealed to the Building/Flood Board of Adjustment and Appeals, but it ruled in favor of the city.

The Bairs subsequently lawyered up and filed a lawsuit in circuit court using a two-prong approach. One says that the city had violated their rights under the Bert J. Harris, Jr., Private Property Rights Protection Act. The other uses the legal doctrine of “Equitable Estoppel” to claim that the market value of their home has been diminished because they started the renovations believing that by issuing the permit, the city had approved their plans, but the Stop Work Order prevents them from finishing the job.

At first, the city’s legal department defended the lawsuit using its staff attorneys. But on Sept. 5, 2013, City Attorney Akin sought and received City Council approval to spend $40,000 to hire Attorney Jeffrey Hinds from the law firm of Smolker, Bartlett, Schlosser, Loeb and Hinds, P.A., to represent the city in the upcoming mediation.

“We were unsuccessful in mediating and the trial is set for (next) April,” Akin told the council at its December 2 work session.

She requested the council’s permission to spend another $160,000 from her Professional Services Budget to have the same law firm represent the city at the trial. On Dec. 5 the council unanimously voted to approve that expendure.
Article published on Thursday, Dec. 12, 2013
Copyright © Tampa Bay Newspapers: All rights reserved.
Printable Version E-mail article
NuSmile
Featured Print Advertisers
NuSmile Dental
13611 Park Blvd., Suite G
Seminole
(727) 475-7866

Web site        View Ad
:)
Abbey Carpet & Floor of Largo
13120 66th St. N.
Largo
(727) 524-1445

Web site        View Ad
:)
Florida Center for Back & Neck Pain
Dr. Greg Hollstrom
11444 Seminole Blvd.
Largo
(727) 393-6100

Web site        View Ad
:)
Custom Couture of Clearwater
(727) 735-8407
By appointment please.

Web site        View Ad
:)
Flooring America of Seminole
9012 Seminole Blvd.
Seminole
(727) 397-5509

Web site        View Ad
:)
Oakhurst & East Bay Medical
13020 Park Blvd., Seminole
(727) 393-3404
3800 East Bay Dr., Largo
(727) 539-0505

Web site        View Ad
:)
Tampa Bay Newspapers
Online Advertising
For information, e-mail
webmaster@tbnweekly.com
:)
Online Services Directory
MEDICAL DIRECTORY   ONLINE DINING GUIDE
MEDICAL DIRECTORY ONLINE DINING GUIDE
AUTOMOTIVE GUIDE REAL ESTATE GUIDE
AUTOMOTIVE GUIDE REAL ESTATE GUIDE
TBN 27/7
Tampa Bay Newspapers
9911 Seminole Blvd.,
Seminole, FL 33772
Phone: (727) 397-5563
Fax: (727) 397-5900
Submit News